Deutschlandfunk Kultur am 4. März 2019 mit einer Stimme der Vernunft:
„Die Privatisierung der Klimafrage ist falsch“
Ralf Fücks im Gespräch mit Korbinian Frenzel
Der Klimawandel ist in vollem Gang – müssen wir nun alle die Verantwortung übernehmen, das Auto stehen lassen, nicht mehr fliegen? Falsche Frage, meint der Autor und Politiker Ralf Fücks. Moralischer Druck sei das Letzte, was hilft.
Ralf Fücks, geschäftsführender Gesellschafter des Zentrums Liberale Moderne, lange Vorstand der Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung und davor Senator für Umwelt und Stadtentwicklung in Bremen, hält diese Debatte nicht für zielführend. Im Gegenteil: Er spricht sich ausdrücklich dagegen aus, bei der Klimafrage die persönliche Verantwortung jedes Einzelnen in den Vordergrund zu stellen. [...] Fücks warnte ausdrücklich davor, zu viel moralischen Druck auf die Menschen aufzubauen. Je mehr der Druck erhöht werde – „Du darfst dies nicht, du darfst das nicht“ – desto stärker werde die gesellschaftliche Polarisierung zwischen Mahnern und denen, die trotzig am Status quo festhielten. Das führe politisch in die Sackgasse, sagte er.
Ganzen Beitrag beim Deutschlandfunk lesen.
Der heftigste vulkanische Ausbruch der letzten 10.000 Jahre auf der Südhalbkugel ereignete sich in der Antarktis. Bisher ging man davon aus, dass sich der Ausbruch vor mehr als 8000 Jahren abspielte. Neue Forschungsergebnisse brachten nun eine faustdicke Überraschung: Der Ausbruch ist “nur” knapp 4000 Jahre her, also halb so alt. Dies ist insbesondere wichtig, da große Ausbrüche das globale Klima für einige Jahre abkühlen. Aber wenn man nicht weiß, wann die Ausbrüche stattfanden, kann man auch die klimatischen Effekte nicht korrekt einordnen. Pressemitteilung des Spanish National Research Council (CSIC) vom 26. November 2018, via ScienceDaily:
A large volcanic eruption shook Deception Island 3,980 years ago
This powerful eruption occurred in Deception Island 3,980 years ago and not 8,300 as previously thought.
A large volcanic eruption shook Deception Island, in Antarctica, 3,980 years ago, and not 8,300, as it was previously thought, according to an international study published in Scientific Reports, in which researchers from the Institute of Earth Sciences Jaume Almera have participated. This event was the largest eruption in the austral continent during the Holocene (the last 11,700 years after the last great glaciation on Earth), and was comparable in volume of ejected rock to the Tambora volcano eruption in 1815. The eruption formed the caldera of the volcano, one of the most active in Antarctica, with more than 20 eruptions registered in the last 200 years.
In the study, whose first author was Dermot Antoniades, from the University of Laval, Canada have taken part researchers from the Universities of Barcelona (UB), Salamanca (USAL), and Cambridge and Leicester (UK), CREAF, the Centre for Research, and Monitoring and Evaluation of the Sierra de Guadarrama National Park, and Centre for Hydrographic Studies (CEDEX).
According to the age published in this new study, a volcanic eruption caldera collapse type took place 3980 years ago. The emptying of the magmatic chamber, the zone of magma accumulation that fuelled the eruption, during this violent eruptive event caused a sudden pressure drop which in turn caused the collapse of the upper part of the volcano. As a result, a depression between 8 and 10 kilometres in diameter was formed, which is what today gives to Deception Island its particular horseshoe shape. The caldera collapse would have caused a seismic event of great magnitude whose trace was recorded in the sediments accumulated in the lakes’ bottom of Livingstone Island.
The lacustrine sediment cores were recovered during the Antarctic campaigns of the HOLOANTAR project, between 2012 and 2014. This fieldwork was lead and coordinated by Marc Oliva, then researcher at Instituto de Geografia e Ordenamento of the University of Lisboa and now Ramon y Cajal researcher at University of Barcelona (UB). Oliva is coauthor of this study.
“The initial objective of the study was purely climatic, since we wanted to reconstruct the climate fluctuations of this region for the last 11,700 years using different proxies found in the sediments of the Byers Peninsula lakes, about 40 kilometres north of Deception Island. However, the presence of a different sediment layer in all lakes and of the same age after a thick layer of tephra surprised us,” said Sergi Pla, researcher at CREAF and coauthor of the study. “Later geochemical and biological analyses indicated us that these sediments had terrestrial origin and were deposited abruptly in the lake’s bottom. These results suggested the occurrence of a major earthquake that affected all this area; put us on the track that, perhaps, we were not facing a common earthquake but the one generated by the collapse of the caldera of the Deception Island volcano. From here on, we pulled the thread,” explained Santiago Giralt, researcher at ICTJA-CSIC and co-author of the study.
The exact date of the eruption was obtained using different geochemical, petrological and paleolimnological techniques applied on the sediment cores from 4 lakes of the Byers Peninsula from Livingston island. These sedimentary records contained several direct and indirect pieces of evidence of the volcanic event that occurred in Deception Island. “The recovered sedimentary records showed a common pattern: first the volcanic ash from Deception Island eruption, overlaid by a sediment layer almost one meter thick composed by material dragged from the lakes’ shores to their bottom due to the large earthquake and, finally, the common lake sediments, which are characterized by an alternation of clays and mosses,” explained Santiago Giralt.
One of the challenges that faced this study was to characterize the origin of the ashes produced during the volcanic eruption. For that, pressure and temperature conditions of the magmas that originated this eruption were calculated using the ashes present in the sediment cores. “Using this methodology, we were able to estimate the depth of all studied samples and to determine if they were part of the same magma and eruptive episode,” said Antonio Álvarez Valero, researcher from the University of Salamanca (USAL) and co-author of this study.
The study also estimates that the eruption had a Volcanic Explosive Index (VEI) around 6 which possibly makes it the largest known Holocene eruptive episode in the Antarctic continent. “This colossal episode of eruptive caldera collapse ejected between 30 and 60 cubic kilometres of ash, comparable in volume to the eruption of the Tambora volcano in 1815, an event that is attributed to a global temperature cooling that resulted in a series of bad harvests in Europe, in what is known as the “year without summer,” explains Adelina Geyer, ICTJA-CSIC researcher and co-author of the study.
“It is very important to be able to date this type of eruptions that allow us to understand the climatic changes caused by volcanic eruptions, in this particular case at high austral latitudes,” adds the Geyer. As suggested by this study, this eruption could have had significant climatic and ecological impacts in a large area of the southern region, although more studies and new data are needed to precisely characterize what the real effects on the climate of this large eruptive event.
Paper: Dermot Antoniades, Santiago Giralt, Adelina Geyer, Antonio M. Álvarez-Valero, Sergi Pla-Rabes, Ignacio Granados, Emma J. Liu, Manuel Toro, John L. Smellie, Marc Oliva. The timing and widespread effects of the largest Holocene volcanic eruption in Antarctica. Scientific Reports, 2018; 8 (1) DOI: 10.1038/s41598-018-35460-x